This is why I think they're going to spend years before this sees the light of dayView on YouTube
What was predicted Chamath argued in early December 2020 that DeepMind/Google would likely withhold AlphaFold for years before it “saw the light of day,” implying there would not be a broad public release of AlphaFold (or an equivalent, high‑capability protein-structure tool) for several years due to ethical/control concerns.
What actually happened
-
AlphaFold 2 paper and open‑source code (July 2021)
- On 15 July 2021, DeepMind’s AlphaFold 2 was published in Nature, accompanied by open‑source code for the model implementation. (en.wikipedia.org)
- DeepMind’s own blog and GitHub confirm that AlphaFold’s v2.0 inference pipeline was released as open source in mid‑July 2021, freely available to anyone. (github.com)
This is roughly 7 months after the December 2020 podcast, not “years.”
-
AlphaFold Protein Structure Database (global access starting July 22, 2021)
- On 22 July 2021, DeepMind and EMBL‑EBI launched the AlphaFold Protein Structure Database (AlphaFold DB), initially providing ~350–365k predicted structures covering nearly the complete human proteome and 20 model organisms, all freely accessible online. (en.wikipedia.org)
- This database is explicitly described as an openly accessible resource intended to put the “power of AlphaFold into the world’s hands.” (deepmind.google)
-
Massive further expansion (2022 onward)
- In July 2022, DeepMind and EMBL‑EBI expanded AlphaFold DB to provide predicted structures for “nearly all catalogued proteins known to science,” over 200 million proteins, again freely downloadable and integrated into core bioinformatics resources. (deepmind.google)
- By 2023–2024, the database contained over 214 million structures and remained openly accessible. (academic.oup.com)
-
Ethical/biological risk handling
- DeepMind did conduct an ethics and safety review, but their public post on AlphaFold’s release states they chose broad open release (code and DB) and report no known misuse, rather than holding the technology back for years. (deepmind.google)
Why this contradicts the prediction
- Chamath’s claim was that DeepMind/Google would not let AlphaFold (or an equivalent high‑capability tool) “see the light of day” for years due to control/ethical concerns.
- In reality, within about 7–8 months of the December 2020 discussion, DeepMind:
- Published the core AlphaFold 2 methodology in a top journal,
- Open‑sourced the inference code, and
- Launched a freely accessible global database of hundreds of thousands, then hundreds of millions, of AlphaFold predictions.
- This is a rapid and very broad release, not a multi‑year delay. While AlphaFold is a structure‑prediction system rather than a full generative protein-design suite, it is precisely the capability discussed at the time and has become a foundational, openly available tool for protein design and structural biology worldwide.
Given this timeline and breadth of access, Chamath’s forecast that the technology would be held back from broad release “for years” is clearly falsified.