Chamath @ 00:56:40Inconclusive
economygovernment
No G8 country will return to sustained fiscal budget surpluses of the type seen in the U.S. during the Clinton administration; such surpluses will not recur in future decades.
there's not going to be a single G8 country that all of a sudden moves away and starts printing surpluses. It happened almost as an accident, an aberration during the Clinton administration. It'll never happen again.View on YouTube
Explanation
Available data since the August 2023 prediction show that Chamath’s view is so far consistent with reality, but the claim is about future decades (“It’ll never happen again”), so it cannot be decisively tested yet.
-
Status since the prediction:
- OECD data for 2023 show that most advanced economies, including the G7, are running fiscal deficits; only six OECD members ran overall surpluses, led by Norway, and these do not include any G7 country. This indicates that none of the G7/G8 has recently “moved away and started printing surpluses.” (oecd.org)
- Germany, one of the more fiscally conservative G7 members, still recorded a general government deficit of about 2.1% of GDP in 2023, not a surplus. (destatis.de)
- Canada has continued to post federal budget deficits through 2024–25 and into 2025–26, not surpluses. (reuters.com)
- Aggregate analyses based on IMF forecasts show G7 debt ratios remaining high or rising through 2029, implying continued structural deficits rather than a shift to Clinton‑style sustained surpluses. (visualcapitalist.com)
- IMF- and media-based assessments emphasize that major advanced economies like the U.S., UK, France, and others face persistent deficits and rising debt trajectories absent major fiscal reforms. (ft.com)
-
Why the prediction can’t be fully judged yet:
- Chamath’s statement is effectively a very long‑horizon claim: that “there’s not going to be a single G8 country” that returns to sustained budget surpluses akin to the U.S. in the late 1990s, and that this will “never happen again.” That implies a multi‑decade time frame.
- As of November 2025, only a bit more than two years have elapsed since the prediction. Even if all G7/G8 members are currently in deficit (which they are), that does not logically prove that none of them will run sustained surpluses at any point over the coming decades.
Because the horizon of the prediction extends far beyond the data we can observe today, the correct evaluation is that it is too early to tell whether his "never again" claim will ultimately be right or wrong. Hence the result is classified as inconclusive.